The High-Cholesterol Paradox
Based upon European WAPF Conference 2014 presentation accredited by:
The Naturopathic Nutrition Association,
Federation of Nutritional Practitioners (FNTP)
British Association of Applied Nutrition (BAAN),
British Association of Nutritional Therapy (BANT)
Glyn Wainwright MSc MBCS CITP CEng - Independent Researcher, Leeds UK
Being told you have ‘high cholesterol’ is commonly taken as a sign of an unhealthy destiny. Research suggests that for many elderly people the news that they have ‘high cholesterol’ is more often
associated with good health and longevity1.For over 50 years this has been a paradox, the ‘High-Cholesterol Paradox’. What is really going on?
Hypothesis becomes Dogma
In the 1950s the prestigious American MD, Dr Ancel Keys2, supported a popular theory that heart disease was caused by dietary Fats and Cholesterol (Lipids) circulating in the blood. In 1972 a British Professor, Dr John Yudkin3, published a book called ‘Pure, White and Deadly’ which proposed over-consumption of refined sugar as the leading cause of diabetes and heart disease. The science
Until the 1970s there had been a small but consistent percentage of overweight and obese people in the population. By the 1980s obesity rates had begun to climb significantly. This sudden
acceleration of obesity is very closely associated with the adoption of new high-sugar, low-fat
formulations in processed foods - the consequences of the McGovern report recommendations being
adopted around the world. Advice to reduce our intake of saturated fats, obtained from meat and dairy, caused a rise in the use of plant based oils and so-called ‘vegetable fats’. This was misleadingly promoted as healthy. The biochemical destiny of dietary ‘Saturated Fat’ is not the same as that of excess ‘Carbohydrates and Sugars’.
Fats do not cause obesity or disease. It is the excess sugars (glucose and fructose - High Fructose Corn Syrup HFCS) which create abdominal
The erroneous idea, and fear, of artery blocking fats was exploited to market fat substitutes. Invite anyone talking about ‘artery blocking fats’ to hold a pat of butter in a closed fist. As the butter melts and runs out between their fingers, ask ‘How do fats, which are evolved to be fluids at body temperature, block the vascular ‘pipes’ in our bodies?’
Plant oils are not the natural lipids for maintaining healthy human or animal cell membranes. Animal sourced fats, and essential fatty acids (EFA), are identical to those we require for the maintenance of the healthy human body.
Let us explore some more big anomalies in the last 40 years of dietary health guidance.
Good Cholesterol? Bad Cholesterol? Spot the Difference?All biochemists can confirm that all cholesterol molecules throughout the known universe are
identical in every respect. So how can there be ‘good’ or ‘bad’ cholesterol. It is now possible to
frighten people with unscientific descriptions like ‘Good’ and ‘Bad’ when talking about cholesterol.
This single misleading description may have prevented a whole generation from knowing the true causes of the very real disturbance in the levels of fatty nutrients
(Lipids) circulating in our blood4.
If the total blood serum cholesterol (TBSC) is high and the organs are getting enough lipids, the blood lipid circulation is healthy. The large parcels of fatty nutrients (LDL lipids) sent by the liver are consumed by our organs (receptor-mediated endocytosis) and the smaller fatty wrappers and left-over lipids (HDL Lipids) return to the liver. The Fatty Nutrients (LDL) and the recycled lipids (HDL) are in balance. Such a healthy-lipid ‘High-Cholesterol’ person is well nourished and likely to have a long and healthy life.
If the total blood serum cholesterol is high but the fatty nutrient droplets (LDLs) have sugar-damaged labels, the organs are unable to recognise and feed on them. The supply of fatty nutrients to organs is broken. The liver continues to supply fatty nutrients (albeit with damaged LDL labels), but the organs’ receptors are unable to recognise them. The organs thus become starved of their fattynutrients. Like badly labelled parcels in a postal service, the sugar-damaged lipids build up in the blood (raised LDL) and fewer empty wrappers are returned to the liver (low HDL). LDL (erroneously called ‘bad’ cholesterol) is raised in the blood, awaiting clearance by the liver. There is less HDL (erroneously called ‘good’ cholesterol) being returned by the organs. High Cholesterol (high levels of total blood serum cholesterol TBSC) when caused by damage to the LDL lipid parcels is a sign that lipid circulation is broken. These fats (LDL) will be scavenged to become visceral fats, deposited around the abdomen. This type of damage is associated with poor health. So it really doesn’t matter how high your total blood serum cholesterol (TBSC) is. What really counts is the damaged condition of the blood’s fatty nutrient parcels
(LDL lipids). In our research review of metabolic syndromes4 (e.g. diabetes, heart
disease, obesity, arthritis and dementia) we explained that the major cause of lipid damage was sugar-related.
Sugar Damage (AGEs)
The abbreviation AGE (Advanced Glycation End-product) is used to describe any
sugar-damaged protein. As we age, excessive amounts of free sugars in the
blood5 may eventually cause damage quicker than the body can repair it. The
sugars attach by a chemical reaction and the sugar called fructose is known tobe 10 times more reactive, and therefore more dangerous than our normal blood
sugar (glucose). Since the 1970s we have been using increasing quantities of
refined fructose (from high-fructose corn syrup). Its appealing sweetness, and
ability to suppress the ‘no longer hungry’ receptor6 (ghrelin receptor) is drivingexcessive food intake. Its ability to damage our fatty nutrients and lipid
circulation is also driving waist-line obesity and its associated health problems4,7.
Checking for Damage in our Lipids There is a ‘simple to administer’ commonly available blood test used to check for
sugar-damage. It is used to check the proteins in the blood of people who are
diabetic or at risk of becoming diabetic. It tests for Glycated Haemoglobin
(HbA1c) by counting the proportion of damaged molecules (per 1000) of
Haemoglobin protein in the blood (mmol/mol). Researchers looking at ways of
testing for damage to lipids, have found that sugar-damaged blood protein test
(HbA1c), presents a very reasonable approximation of the state of sugar-damage
in the blood lipids. Until there is a good general test for sugar-damage in blood
lipids, this test (HbA1c) could be a sensible surrogate. This is a better way of
assessing health than a simple cholesterol test (TBSC).
Improved sugar-damaged blood protein (HbA1c) scores in diabetic patients is
accompanied by improvements in their lipid profiles. This could be very useful to
anyone wanting to improve health outcomes by managing lifestyle and nutrition.
Clinical Consequences of Lowering Cholesterol
In 2008 Dr Luca Mascitelli asked me to examine a paper by Xia et al8. It was very
interesting to note that lowering cholesterol by as little as 10% (molecular in cellwalls) in the pancreas (pancreatic beta-cells) prevented the release of insulin
(cholesterol-mediated exocytosis). This paper described a mechanism by which
‘cholesterol lowering drugs’ directly cause diabetes. It was known that in statin
drug trials which looked at glucose (blood sugar) control there was poor bloodsugar
control in the statin user groups. Since 2011 the USA government (FDA)
required statins to carry a warning about the risk of causing diabetes9.
The healthy human brain may only be 5% of body weight but it requires over25% of the body’s cholesterol. The nervous system uses huge quantities of
cholesterol for insulation, protection and structure (myelin). F W Pfrieger et al.10
have shown that the formation of the memory (synapses) is dependent on good
supplies of cholesterol. Post-mortem studies show that depleted cholesterol levels in the cerebrospinal
fluids are a key feature of dementias. It was also reported that behavioural
changes and personality changes are associated with low levels of cerebrospinal
cholesterol. In another review paper on Dementia we commented extensively on the damage
done by fructose and the depletion of cholesterol availability. Low cholesterol
levels in the nervous system are not conducive to good mental health.
Consequences of Lowering Cholesterol.
Read the complete article here