FB-TW

Showing posts with label HPS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label HPS. Show all posts

Monday, April 8, 2013

HDL Particle Concentration is a Better Predictor of Coronary Heart Disease - Honigberg


HDL Particle Concentration is a Better Predictor of Coronary Heart Disease Risk than HDL Cholesterol

Robert Honigberg, MD

Several recent, high-profile clinical trial failures of experimental high density lipoprotein (HDL)-raising therapies has prompted members of the scientific and medical communities to question the prognostic value of HDL as an indicator of coronary heart disease (CHD) risk. However, new research suggests that we should update clinical guidelines with a more predictive measurement of HDL-related risk.

The study, which evaluated the independent associations of high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) and high density lipoprotein particle (HDL-P) concentrations with CHD, suggests that HDL-P may be a more accurate indicator of cardiovascular risk than HDL-C. The findings were published in the current issue of the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

Researchers analyzed blood samples obtained at study onset from 5,598 middle-aged men and women free of cardiovascular disease who participated in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA), a prospective observational study initiated and overseen by the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute. Participants were followed for a mean of six years for incident CHD events—including angina, heart attack, and coronary heart disease death.

The researchers concluded that baseline levels of HDL-C and HDL-P were both inversely associated with CHD events and carotid atherosclerosis in this study population. However, after adjusting each HDL measure for the other and for LDL-P, joint analysis demonstrated that the inverse relationship for CV risk persisted for HDL-P but no longer existed for HDL-C. The more consistent inverse association between cardiovascular endpoints and HDL-P has also been shown in other studies including the HPS, MR-FIT, EPIC-NORFOLK and VA-HIT trials. In the accompanying editorial, Emil deGoma and Dan Rader noted that HDL-P may be more useful to refine cardiovascular risk and to evaluate novel HDL-directed therapies.

In light of this study’s findings, it is likely that more research will be conducted which extends beyond traditional HDL-C measurement to sort out the different functional properties of HDL. We at LipoScience contend that measuring HDL-P in clinical practice can lead to better patient treatment decisions, particularly as the LDL particle number is brought under control. Obviously this is a provocative subject, and I’d love for you share your thoughts in the comment section.
==================================================================
Read the full article here.

Friday, December 21, 2012

Real Life vs. Pharma Company Studies - Kendrick

Real Life vs. Pharma Company Studies

December 21, 2012

At what point, exactly, does credibility snap? When does the difference between what we are told, and what we observe, reach such a state of dissonance that it is no longer possible to believe both. Sometimes it seems the answer is ….never.

Here is one example. The clinical trials on statins found that they have virtually no adverse effects. Or, to be a little more accurate, that adverse events were virtually identical to placebo. Here, for example, is part of the press release from the Heart Protection Study (HPS). This was the last major placebo controlled statin study done in people with already diagnosed cardiovascular disease.

As the benefits of statins are now thought so wonderful it would be considered unethical to do a placebo controlled study anymore. You would be withholding statins from people who need them. Which means that you are not going to get any more evidence in this area – ever again. The HPS results were published around ten years ago, and the press release contained the following

‘Although muscle pain was reported by the participants, this happened about as commonly among those allocated the active simvastatin as among those allocated the placebo tablets. Despite 20,536 randomised patients having been followed for an average of five years, blood tests among people reporting muscle symptoms found only 11 simvastatin-allocated patients and 6 placebo-allocated patients with a rise in the muscle enzyme creatine kinase (CK) to more than 10 times the upper limit of normal Of these, 14 met the definition for “myopathy” (i.e. muscle symptoms associated with such CK elevations) of whom 10 were in the simvastatin group and 4 in the placebo group.’

http://www.ctsu.ox.ac.uk/~hps/June02QandA.shtml

Teasing these figures out a little more it seems that an extra six people taking simvastatin suffered muscle ‘problems’ than those taking the placebo. This is six people, out of more than ten thousand taking simvastatin. This represents in one thousand seven hundred and eight 1/1708 (over five years).
If this were true, then muscle problems should be exceedingly rare. The average GP with about two hundred of their fifteen hundred patients taking a statin should see a patient with muscle pains/problems about once every twenty five years. At this rate, you would not even know you had a problem.

Yet, wrapped around my copy of the BMJ last week was an advert for rosuvastatin [Crestor]. The strap line shouted out ‘Myalgia on his initial statin?’ [Myalgia is the medical word for muscle pain]. The main message the advert was… ‘If your patient was suffering muscle pains on their initial statin, they should switch to Crestor 5mg.’

Their ‘initial statin’ will almost certainly be Simvastatin 40mg. The drug, and the dose, used in the HPS study. The same drug, and the same dose recommended by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE).

Now, you do not run an expensive advertising campaign without doing a lot of market research first. What the market research must have told AstraZeneca – who make Crestor – is that a lot of people are suffering muscle pains on 40mg simvastatin.

Which means that simvastatin, which caused no discernible increase in muscle pains in the clinical study…… actually creates such a massive burden of muscle problems that a pharmaceutical campaign is running a major advertising campaign highlighting this, exact, adverse event.

What does this tell us, gentle reader? It tells us many things. Some of which would be considerable slanderous if I said them out loud. The most outstanding thing it tells me is that, although we have all been repeatedly informed that statins have no more side-effects than placebo, I now find that AstraZeneca encouraging doctors to switch statins due to the burden of side-effects.

F Scott Fitzgerald opined that …“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function.’

I would suggest that there comes a point where you have to decide between which idea is right, and which is wrong. With regard to statins, I did this many years ago when I recognised that they cause a gigantic burden of adverse effects, with muscle pain the single most outstanding. I knew that the clinical trials had somehow or another managed to bury this fact.

Yet, when I speak to most doctors they continue to tell me that statins have very few side-effects, as do most opinion leaders. This belief, whilst AstraZeneca starts up an advertising campaign based on side-effects reported by doctors. F Scott Fitzgerland would be impressed by all these first class intellects. I just despair of them.
============================================================
Read the complete article here.